GoHotelly
3-star hotel

Trailing Yew

Trailing Yew offers simple, kid-friendly lodging in Monhegan, ME. Enjoy breakfast & dinner, close to Marshall Point Lighthouse and Monhegan Museum.

55 Lobster Cove Rd, Monhegan, ME 04852, United States View on map
9.4/10
Exceptional Based on 49 recent guest reviews
Kid-friendly
What recent guests emphasize

Rustic Charm with Homestyle Hospitality

Guests appreciate the simple, nostalgic lodging and hearty homemade meals, paired with peaceful island views and welcoming staff. The property offers a unique, no-frills experience that captures the spirit of Monhegan Island living.

Guests often praise

  • Hearty, homemade breakfasts and dinners featuring fresh, local ingredients
  • Friendly, helpful staff providing personal touches like coffee delivered to rooms
  • Cozy, character-filled rooms with rustic decor evoking a nostalgic feel
  • Scenic views of the harbor, island, and surrounding waters
  • Pet-friendly atmosphere and welcoming community dining experience

Worth knowing

  • Most rooms do not have electricity; lighting is often by kerosene lamps
  • Shared bathroom facilities add to the rustic experience, not suited for those seeking modern conveniences
  • WiFi is only available in limited outdoor areas near the main office
  • Dinner service is seasonal, currently only offered in May and October
  • Lunch is available midday but can be popular and sells out quickly

Best for

  • Travelers seeking an authentic, peaceful island retreat with historic charm
  • Visitors who appreciate communal dining and homemade, generous meals
  • Guests looking for a quiet, rustic setting away from modern distractions
  • Pet owners wanting to bring their dogs along for a relaxed stay
  • Visitors interested in nearby lighthouses and island cultural sites
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Trailing Yew

Set on Monhegan Island, 55 Lobster Cove Rd offers a rustic lodging experience through a compound of six buildings, most without electricity. This simple accommodation focuses on maintaining a traditional island atmosphere, with kerosene lamps and shared bathrooms, reflecting a distinctive 19th-century feel appreciated by visitors seeking an authentic stay away from modern amenities.

Guests can enjoy homemade breakfast and dinner services, with breakfast often highlighted for its quality and variety, including fresh yogurt and granola. Meals promote a communal atmosphere, as many reviewers note sharing tables and conversations with fellow visitors. The property also offers pet-friendly options and personalized touches like coffee delivered directly to rooms each morning.

The location benefits guests interested in sightseeing and recreation on Monhegan Island. Nearby attractions include the historic Marshall Point Lighthouse & Museum and the Monhegan Lighthouse, both highly rated for their charm and local significance. Art and history enthusiasts may appreciate the close proximity to the Monhegan Museum of Art & History.

Trailing Yew appeals mainly to travelers seeking a quiet, nostalgic island retreat with a simple lifestyle rather than visitors looking for luxury or extensive facilities. While some accommodations have electricity and WiFi is available near the main office, the experience is generally rustic and best suited for those embracing a slow-paced, nature-focused visit.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Kid-friendly
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

MO
Melva Olson Apr 05, 2026
10

This is the most fun place I have stayed at for years. Breakfast was amazing…homemade everything from their own yogurt to their yummy granola! More food than you can eat!! The rooms reminded me of my grandmother’s room. Well run with wonderful people!! We will return!

MT
Mandy Tetzlaff Apr 04, 2026
10

We stayed one night at The Trailing Yew in the cabin building, a cozy, stand-alone structure tucked away from the main house, and it was the perfect example of a classic Monhegan stay. The room was simple, clean, and full of character, with absolutely stunning views overlooking the harbor and the village. We (and our pup) also loved that the property is pet-friendly. The staff were welcoming and incredibly helpful from the moment we arrived. Each morning, they deliver fresh coffee directly to your room at your requested time. Breakfast was lovely - fresh, homemade, and enjoyed in a beautiful setting. If you’re looking for an authentic, peaceful island experience with exceptional hospitality and breathtaking views, The Trailing Yew is a wonderful choice. We can’t wait to return.

JRB
J. R. Baldini (Niagara Wedding Chapel) Mar 16, 2026
10

I have stayed in all the accommodations on this property except the Seagull starting from 1974 when Josephine was still there. Even the 'trailer' when it actually was a trailer lol. The food has always been good home cooking and plentiful. I have been teaching art workshops on the island since 2002 and many of my students have also enjoyed their stay at the Yew. Just listed the dates for my 2024 workshop and will be sharing the TY info with them. Still a few friends on the island from back then that we look forward to visiting with again.

JC
Jesse Carlson Mar 04, 2026
10

We were so happy with our stay! Very lovely room, good breakfasts, complementary coffee service each morning, and some incredible views of Manana and the harbor. We did have electricity in our room in the annex, and there was WiFi on the lawn by the main office. Lunch was very popular and serviced from 12-2pm. Get there early for hand pies! It is good to note that dinner is only served currently in May and October.

CB
Chris Bartlett Feb 21, 2026
10

A beautiful lodging on Monhegan. It is very rustic and we loved that. No electricity in our room, though it is available in some rooms. Kerosene lamps. Shared bathroom. We loved the 19th century feel. Especially nice are the meals... You share a table with other visitors. We met wonderful folks from all over. Highly recommended for a unique experience.

JC
Joe C Feb 17, 2026
10

a very nice rustic Maine Island experience..not fancy but a perfect experience..it reminded me of the old Pennsylvania quaker farmhouse I grew up in. Coffee delivered to your room in the morning, very nice breakfast..

MS
Misty Start Feb 10, 2026
10

My friends and I planned an impromptu visit to the island to celebrate a birthday, and I called all around the island to find someone that could prepare a surprise birthday cake with us with only 24 hours notice. The Trailing Yew graciously said that they could do it with all the frills. When we group arrived, the beautiful cake was ready for us and the team brought out beautiful dishes and serving ware to our outside table overlooking the sea. Everyone commented on how it was the best cake they had ever had ((double layer round vanilla with fresh raspberry filling)). It was such a fun surprise for my friend, and I’m so grateful to the Trailing Yew team for making it happen!

KH
Karly Hannold Jan 11, 2026
10

Wonderful afternoon spent on the island. Accommodations were great takes you away from the hustle and bustle on mainland. Rooms were quaint and simple. Breakfast to order, delicious, mainly all homemade and locally sourced the best pumpkin scones! with time to sit down and chat with everyone else in the building. Loved having the peaceful evening here would like to return.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Trailing Yew

St. George, Maine, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Portland International Jetport invalid time Car
  • Knox County Regional Airport invalid time Car
  • Augusta State Airport invalid time Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Maine. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Marshall Point Lighthouse & Museum 1,458 reviews

Marshall Point Lighthouse & Museum

Marshall Point Rd, Port Clyde, ME 04855, United States

4.8 · Museum
Monhegan Lighthouse 45 reviews

Monhegan Lighthouse

Monhegan, ME 04852, United States

4.8 · Historical Landmark
Monhegan Museum of Art & History 29 reviews

Monhegan Museum of Art & History

1 Light House Hill Rd, Monhegan, ME 04852, United States

4.7 · Museum
People also viewed

Similar Hotels in Maine

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

1441 W Central Ave, Carthage, MO 64836, United States

Days Inn by Wyndham Carthage

Relax at Days Inn by Wyndham Carthage with free breakfast, indoor pool, and hot tub. Rated 3.7 from 554 reviews, near the Battle o...

3.7 (554) View
36012 Airport Rd, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971, United States

Hotel Wave Rehoboth Beach

Stay at Hotel Wave Rehoboth Beach, a 3.5star hotel offering free WiFi, indoor pool, hot tub, and breakfast, close to Rehoboth Be...

3.5 (777) View
12410 Northwest Fwy, Houston, TX 77092

PLATINUM INN AND SUITES

Stay at PLATINUM INN AND SUITES in Houston, TX. Enjoy free WiFi, breakfast, and parking near top attractions like Houston Zoo and...

4.1 (315) View
574 Old East King St, Boone, NC 28607, United States

Blue Ridge Tourist Court

Stay at Blue Ridge Tourist Court in Boone, NC. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, kidfriendly rooms with kitchens, and easy access to App...

5 (116) View
431 Corona Del Mar, Santa Barbara, CA 93103, United States

Old Yacht Club Inn Vacation Rentals

Stay at Old Yacht Club Inn Vacation Rentals in Santa Barbara, CA. Petfriendly inn with free WiFi and parking, near Santa Barbara...

4 (40) View
1402 Toronita St Building B, York, PA 17402, United States

MainStay Suites North - Central York

3.7rated extended stay hotel offering free WiFi, breakfast, and parking. Conveniently located near York County History Center an...

3.7 (48) View
9664 Mason Montgomery Rd, Mason, OH 45040, United States

Marriott Cincinnati Northeast

Rated 4.4 with 1,195 reviews, Marriott Cincinnati Northeast offers indoor & outdoor pools, a gym, restaurant, and easy access to K...

4.4 (1,195) View
101 Granite Run Dr, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

Hilton Garden Inn Lancaster

Relax at Hilton Garden Inn Lancaster with free WiFi, indoor pool, and gym. Just 3 miles from Fulton Opera House and close to Dutc...

4.1 (782) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Trailing Yew? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.